Brooklyn Pizza - Grill

Discover Brooklyn Pizza - Grill in Lancaster, PA, serving authentic NY-style pizza, pasta, subs, wings, and more in a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere. Enjoy dine-in, takeout, or delivery with gluten-free options and friendly service.

Welcome to Brooklyn Pizza - Grill

Taste the Difference.

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill
Brooklyn Pizza - Grill
Brooklyn Pizza - Grill
Brooklyn Pizza - Grill

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill welcomes you into a casual haven for New York-style pizza lovers. Nestled at 1750 Oregon Pike in Lancaster, PA, our pizzeria offers a slice of the Big Apple with a local twist. Whether you crave a crispy grandma pizza, savory wings, or hearty subs, we serve up favorites made with fresh ingredients. Our cozy atmosphere welcomes families, students, and tourists alike, making every visit feel like a home game. We’re proud to be Lancaster’s top spot for authentic Italian comfort food, delivering quality through every dish.

Our menu balances tradition and innovation—think gluten-free crusts and vegetarian options paired with the classics. From quick bites during busy lunch hours to relaxed dinners under our warm lighting, Brooklyn Pizza delivers community, flavor, and a genuine New York vibe right here in Lancaster. Stop by or call +1 717-509-4444. Your New York-style adventure starts here.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

1750 Oregon Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601, United States

Phone

+1 717-509-4444

About

The Culinary Story

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill
Brooklyn Pizza - Grill
Brooklyn Pizza - Grill
Brooklyn Pizza - Grill

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill stands as a cornerstone of Lancaster’s culinary scene, blending authentic New York flavors with friendly service. Since opening, we’ve built a reputation for our signature white pizza, crispy wings, and hearty subs, popular among locals and visitors alike. Our founder’s vision aimed to create a comforting space where people gather around fresh, quality ingredients. We source our toppings and dough to meet the standards of NYC pizza artisans, but with a personal Lancaster charm.

Our team is passionate about food and community—we often host catering events and support local initiatives. Every dish tells a story of our dedication to flavor and hospitality. Our commitment extends beyond just pizza; we care about your experience, from speedy service to a clean, cozy environment. We’re more than a restaurant; we’re a neighborhood hub where friends meet, families relax, and students indulge. Come taste Lancaster’s best-kept pizza secret and enjoy a slice of New York right in Pennsylvania.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday11 AM–9 PM
  • Monday10:30 AM–9 PM
  • Tuesday10:30 AM–9 PM
  • Wednesday10:30 AM–9 PM
  • Thursday10:30 AM–9 PM
  • Friday10:30 AM–10 PM
  • Saturday10:30 AM–10 PM

At Brooklyn Pizza - Grill, we take pride in crafting exceptional food and providing a friendly, welcoming vibe. Our menu features iconic NY-style pizzas, including thin, crispy crusts, flavorful sauces, and generous toppings. We serve pasta, wings, subs, burgers, and more, all made fresh daily. Besides our delicious offerings, we provide multiple service options—dine-in, takeaway, curbside pickup, and no-contact delivery—to fit your busy schedule.

Our restaurant is wheelchair-accessible, ensuring everyone can enjoy our comfort food. We also accommodate children with high chairs and a kids' menu. Service remains swift, especially during peak hours, with options to reserve seats for groups or families. Our Wi-Fi and casual setup make Brooklyn Pizza - Grill perfect for solo lunch breaks or family dinners. We keep prices fair, typically between $10 to $20, guaranteeing you value with every bite. Whether you’re a local or just passing through Lancaster, Brooklyn Pizza offers a community-focused spot to savor great food.

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill

Brooklyn Pizza - Grill features a welcoming exterior with a wheelchair-accessible parking lot and inviting outdoor seating. Our outdoor vibe captures the lively, friendly spirit of Brooklyn, with a casual, family-friendly atmosphere. When weather permits, enjoy your pizza al fresco, soaking in Lancaster’s lively street scene. Our outdoor setup includes pet-friendly spaces for dogs, so your furry friends can join the fun. The building’s facade reflects a classic pizzeria with colorful signage and a cozy storefront that beckons passersby to step inside.

Inside, our ambiance balances laid-back comfort with a touch of Brooklyn’s urban edge. The outdoor spaces make Brooklyn Pizza - Grill an ideal spot for quick bites, casual dinners, or catching up with friends under the open sky.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Might be the best pizza around. It’s hard to tell how good a place is based on reviews. All these shops have over 4 stars and they’re almost all mediocre. Brooklyn stands out. Maybe the best white pizza I’ve ever had. Everyone skimps on the ricotta nowadays for some reason, but not these guys. Excellent.

J
Josiah S.

The best gluten free pizza in Lancaster! I have tried at least 5 different gluten free pizzas around town and this one blows the others out of the water. Actually tastes like an authentic Italian pizza only the crust is a little on the crunchy side which is pretty standard for gluten free. However it doesn’t taste like cardboard like all the others- it has a really nice flavor. My husband (not gluten free) recommends the Brooklyn Full House pizza.

E
Elizabeth C.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Brooklyn Pizza Grill – A Foodie’s Dream in Lancaster Brooklyn Pizza Grill is a true gem in Lancaster. Their pepperoni square pizza is absolutely incredible—crispy, cheesy, and packed with flavor. But the real standout? The crust. Most places treat it like an afterthought, but here it’s crunchy, soft, and full of flavor—a perfect finish to every slice. As a self-proclaimed foodie, I’ve had my fair share of wings and garlic knots, and I can confidently say Brooklyn’s are the best I’ve ever had. Perfectly seasoned, cooked just right, and totally crave-worthy. Victor, the owner, is always warm and welcoming—my toddler even asks to stop by just to say hi! You can dine in and enjoy a cozy, friendly atmosphere, or grab a few slices to go. They also offer a great variety by the slice, which is perfect if you want to try a little bit of everything. The food is the real star here, but the reasonable prices are a fantastic bonus. Highly recommend checking this place out—you won’t be disappointed!

P
Paul L.

We stumbled on this place and I’m so glad we did. I haven’t had such good pizza in a long time. The crust is thin and perfectly cooked. The sauce is light and full of flavor. We tried the white pizza and a Margherita. I recommend both!

C
C P.

Visiting the area and found this place accidentally... Believe the hype and reviews online! Hands down best pizza we've had in at least a year. They dont skimp on toppings. Crust was tasty and crispy! Cheese was rich and sauce was amazingly balanced, bright and delicious. Great customer service on the phone and super friendly in person as well. The inside was super clean and all staff busy... order ready in 15 min too! To the oweners (if they see this): thank you for allowing customers to add half or whole toppings and paying half or whole prices! Tooooo many places charge full when u only need half. P.s. if you ever wanna open another location, come to Frederick MD! Lol. ;)

J
Jon D.

Wonderful pizza. Excellent variety. I had the square pepperoni and the taco. Staff recommended a combination that I didn’t know about and saved me money. Always like that. Will be back!

J
John H.